The Policy Trap: Why Safety Documents Don’t Change Behaviour

Let’s be honest.

How many times have you written a policy… only to watch nothing actually change?

You print it.
You file it.
You might even email it round or mention it in a meeting.

And then…
People carry on doing exactly what they were doing before.

“But we’ve got it covered, right?”

This is one of the most common traps I see:

“We just need something in place—just in case.”

That mindset leads to policies that are:

• Written to “tick the box”

• Never read by the people doing the job

• Built around ideal procedures, not real ones

• Designed by one person, in isolation

And then people wonder why the system doesn’t work.

The problem isn’t the document. It’s what it replaces.

Too often, a policy becomes a stand-in for actual leadership.

Instead of:

• Speaking to staff

• Understanding real risks

• Building something together

…someone types up a document and assumes it’s job done.

But you can’t document your way out of a people problem.

If someone’s been stacking pallets dangerously for 10 years, a PDF isn’t going to stop them.
If a supervisor avoids conflict, no procedure will magically give them a backbone.

So what should you be doing first?

Start with how the work actually happens.
Sit in the yard. Watch the task. Ask questions like:

• “Where do you take shortcuts?”

• “What’s awkward or annoying about this?”

• “What would make this safer without slowing you down?”

Then build your policies around that reality—not above it.

What we teach inside The Safety Pro

Our approach flips the usual order.

We don’t start with templates or documents.
We start with how people behave—and why.

That gives you policies that reflect reality.
Not fantasy.

Want the free tool we use to diagnose this?

Want the free tool we use to diagnose this? Join the waitlist.