Why Employees' Responsibilities Under the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974 Aren’t Enough on Their Own

You don’t need to remind most people that they should “take reasonable care” at work.

But if legal duties were enough to keep everyone safe, we wouldn’t still be seeing:

• People skipping PPE

• Shortcuts during tasks

• And a long list of “it’ll be fine” decisions

The Health and Safety at Work Act 1974 spells out employee responsibilities clearly:

• Take care of yourself and others

• Follow training and instructions

• Cooperate with your employer

That’s the theory.

But in the real world, that list doesn’t change much on its own.

The law tells them what to do.

It doesn’t change how they think.

This is where most businesses hit a wall.

They’ve done the briefings.
They’ve ticked the induction box.
They’ve signed everyone off as “competent”.

But behaviours haven’t changed.
The same unsafe habits are still there.

That’s not a training issue.
It’s a culture issue.

Employees’ legal duties mean nothing if the system around them is broken

When I walk onto a site and ask a worker about near misses, and they shrug…
Or when staff don’t raise concerns because they don’t think it’ll be taken seriously…

That’s not just “non-compliance”.

That’s a leadership blind spot.

People won’t follow rules they don’t respect.
And they won’t speak up if no one’s really listening.

Want to make the legal duties actually stick?

Here’s what works better than repeating the rules:

• Sit with them. Watch how the job actually gets done.

• Ask what feels awkward, clunky, or pointless.

• Listen without correcting them right away.

• Spot where your system creates friction or pressure.

Because once you understand the real blockers, you can build something that actually works.

The takeaway?

The Health and Safety at Work Act 1974 gives you a legal baseline.
But it’s your culture, communication, and leadership that turn duties into action.

Start there.

Want the full checklist we use to test if safety responsibilities are actually working on site?
Join the newsletter →